Gnomes lost:
[ x ] Gnomeregan. More to it than that, but that's another thread altogether.
Humans lost:
[ x ] Strom. Though to be fair Strom was more or less abandoned...
[ x ] Alterac. Lost to Orc but there was some betrayal involved. Sounds familiar (*cough*Thermaplugg*cough*)
[ x ] Dalaran. Oh I know, I know but its still a neutral city lead by an inter-racial council. To claim it as a -human- city regardless of past and current political climate just wouldn't be accurate. Even if they finally do declare themselves an Alliance City, they still wouldn't be a -human- city.
[ x ] Gilneas. Another tragedy, yet not on the scale of Gnomeregan even though it was of their own making.
[ x ] Stormwind. That's right. It was sacked once and completely destroyed by the Orc. Completely.
[ ] Stormwind. Sure you rebuilt the city. A beauty and a marvel, yet for various reasons they've failed to retain hold of Westfall, Darkshire, and Lakeshire provinces. They still 'claim' dominion, but have done little about it. Cite the various wars if you like, but the fact still stands. In lieu of the final city to make this list I'll spare you the count of those last three.
[ x ] Lordaeron. Truly a tragedy of Gnomeregan scale and then some, I'll even add. Lordaeron, the crown jewel of Humanity. The symbol of their greatness and might. Betrayed by one of their own (doesn't that sound familiar *cough*Thermaplugg*cough*) to its utter ruin. A complete loss. Fair to say 95%... maybe pushing 98% of its population gone. A fraction of that recovered by the undead, but that still doesn't change that for the humans their fair and illustrious jewel is still gone. An utter tragedy. Interesting that we both lost these two pinnacles around the same time, and nearly under similar circumstance... and yet... we've reclaimed most of ours.
Where are you on yours?
Gnome: 1
Human: 6. Technically 7 counting Stormwind in the first war. 10 counting the provinces... but we'll say 6. You humans need all the help you can get. Remember that.
As it is ruled by a Human, was founded by humans, and is primarily Human, I think Dalaran still counts as ours.
Also, You've reclaimed most? You've 'reclaimed' the doorstep, and you're barely holding that. Barely. It took you how long?
-So the Gnomes, who have one city, haven't reclaimed it. Against Troggs. Troggs.
TROGGS and a few leper Gnomes/Onecrazyguy. What did we reclaim our city from? Orcs. Freakin' hulking demonic infused abominations of adrenaline and musclebrains.
So...who's winning? You've got no city, just a ramshackle staging point that's half irradiated. We've got our city back, plus, we've still got all of our towns and villages.
Yeah, we've lost a lot. But what does that mean? We expanded a lot. We were everywhere, and we ruled a lot until the Demons came a knocking. Demons who, might I remind you, are the apocalyptic kind who have ended hundreds of PLANETS. Yeah, we humans lost to the biggest of the bads, and we still came back for more.
You lost to troggs, and one crazy guy. We've had our betrayal. We avenged ours and made right our mistakes. You're still puzzlin' out how to get a guy out of a hole.
Humans all the way.